Keyport Fishery

Keyport is a favorite place of mine. I've seen this fishery many times, so I decided to try it. It's a cute place, bigger on the inside than from what it looks on the outside. Ample parking as well. I ordered the shrimp platter. The batter was just right! The fries were GOOD!!! They were perfectly crisp AND served hot. All in all, it's a really good meal. Big portion for the price. I'm looking forward to returning!!!

Greatest seafood place for take out. We had shrimp, scallops, both clam chowders and fish cake. Everything was great. Prices are reasonable. Also a fish market inside. Can't wait to go back.

Good friends of ours who have been coming here for years took us for the first time and my husband and i loved it!! The seafood is so fresh and delicious, we got the shrimp and scallop platter. Wish there were places to sit, but you can always go down to the harbor and grab a bench. The line looks long but moves fast. Can’t wait to eat here again!

Keyport Fishery in New Jersey offers a refreshingly honest seafood experience. It’s a no-frills, takeout-only spot that lets the food speak for itself—and it speaks volumes. Located by the bay, this long-standing local favorite is all about freshness and simplicity. The fish is caught locally and cooked to order, which you can taste in every bite. I ordered the haddock fish sandwich, and it was excellent. Served on simple white bread with a side of tartar sauce, it struck a perfect balance. The fish was lightly breaded, golden, and crisp on the outside, moist and flaky inside. The tartar sauce was a great complement—creamy, tangy, and clearly made to enhance rather than overpower. The sandwich was served with fries and coleslaw on the side too. There’s no seating, just the seafood market and take-out counter. They have a strong reputation built on consistency. Service was quick and friendly, even with a steady flow of customers. You can tell they take pride in what they do. Keyport Fishery is the kind of place that doesn’t try to be anything it’s not—and that’s exactly what makes it worth visiting. If you’re after fresh, well-prepared fried seafood served simply and done right, this spot delivers every time.

i ordered fired half scallops and half flounder… the scallops were excellent but the flounder ended up dry… they were still good though and flavorful… oh and they only accept cash…

If you're looking for consistently fresh seafood with unbeatable flavor, Keyport Fishery is a hidden gem you need to try. This no-frills spot might look simple at first glance, but don’t let that fool you — the food here is phenomenal. I usually go for the flounder sandwich, which comes with fries, tartar sauce, coleslaw and lemon wedge. It’s straightforward and classic, but the taste is out of this world — crispy, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. Their clams are always fresh and delicious too. One thing to note: they only accept cash, and there's always a line, especially during Lent, when the place is packed. That said, it’s absolutely worth the wait. But what truly sets Keyport Fishery apart is their hard sauce. I can honestly say it’s the best tartar sauce I’ve ever had in my life — it’s bold, tangy, and adds the perfect kick to anything you order. If you're in the area and craving seafood done right, this spot should be at the top of your list. Just bring cash and come hungry — you won’t be disappointed.

I ordered some crabs. They were great . Miguel evened cleaned them. I enjoyed my experience there. The workers etc were very nice. I’ll keep going there I really enjoyed my experience. Very fresh fish and great cooking. You call other place they always have a sad story. This place has it and delivers!

Nothing beats a combo platter of fresh fried fish. Their tartar sauce is the best tartar sauce I've ever had— so I always end up taking home tons of leftovers. Yeah, I wish I could eat inside, but sitting on the pier and watching birds and fishermen is fun too.